TN Playing Energy Hog: Uses TWICE as much electricity?!

Submitted by Eleanor A on Sun, 01/13/2008 - 17:05.

Sheez. I just got this in the email, from our friends at Democracy for America:

URGENT: Help Tennessee save the planet

You can help stop one of the greatest environmental polluters in the world -- Tennessee.

The United States is the greatest producer of greenhouse gases in the world and Tennessee has the highest individual consumption of electricity in the country. Tennessee is also the greatest average monthly consumer of industrial electricity, using more than twice as much power as much larger states such as Texas and California.

It's downright shocking. Anyone know where they got these numbers? There's more on the email, and what DFA wants us to do about it (support a Bredesen energy proposal) after the jump.

More from DFA:

URGENT: Help Tennessee save the planet
You can help stop one of the greatest environmental polluters in the world -- Tennessee.

The United States is the greatest producer of greenhouse gases in the world and Tennessee has the highest individual consumption of electricity in the country. Tennessee is also the greatest average monthly consumer of industrial electricity, using more than twice as much power as much larger states such as Texas and California.

Because of our factories and energy generation facilities, we are one of the greatest contributor to the problem of climate change in the world and that means we have the greatest responsibility toward making changes.

Right now Gov. Phil Bredesen is putting together a plan to deal with the problem and we need to show him we're behind his efforts. The more support he gets from the public, the greater the impact he can have both inside the government and with private entities that cause the pollution. I'll tell you how you can help in a minute, but first let me tell you what's being considered.

Gov. Bredeson's staff is considering a comprehensive state energy plan that could:

* Create sustainable energy that maximizes our reliance on energy efficiency and renewable energies.
* Initiate sustainable transportation that reduces our need for oil and new highway construction through public transportation and Smart Growth.
* Aid climate protection by reducing our State’s carbon footprint through energy efficiency and sustainable transportation.
* Promote a sustainable economy that relies on technological innovation and jobs created by the sustainable transformation.
* Support clean water and clean air by relying on energy efficiency, compact development, recycling of resources, and reduced consumption.

In addition, Tennessee needs to set targets for energy efficiency and renewable energies with steps on how to meet them over the years. Other states have set goals to reduce existing energy consumption through energy efficiency. Energy targets need to be clear, shared, measurable, and attainable. The State has many “tools” available to effect change - legislation, policy, regulation, financial and technical assistance, and partnerships (especially with TVA and its distributors.)

Now, here's how you can help.

The "rules for activists" say I should write a letter for you to copy and paste into an e-mail that you could send to the appropriate people, but I'm not going to do that here. The crisis we face with climate change is so serious and Tennessee is such a major contributor to the problem, that I'm asking you to make an extra effort so that we can have an even greater impact.

Politicians quickly recognize form letters, but personal letters and phone calls have a much greater impact. Now is the time for us to do all we can to save the environment for future generations.

So, please, take a few minutes and write a personal note to Gov. Bredesen and Ryan Gooch, the state's energy policy director and tell them:

1. Why the issue of climate change is important to you.
2. Why you support a comprehensive energy plan.
3. What actions you'd like the state to consider (feel free to use information from the list above).
4. Pledge your support for their actions.
5. Thank them for acting on these issue.

Be polite. When environmental groups contacted the state on the issue, they found Gov. Bredeson and Mr. Gooch were already considering a strategy. They already want to do the right thing -- they just need an outpouring of support to help them.

Please contact:

Governor Phil Bredesen (phil.bredesen@state.tn.us)
Ryan Gooch, State Energy Policy (ryan.gooch@state.tn.us) 615-741-2994

Thanks for all that you do -- and especially for making an extra effort to help save our planet.

Jim Grinstead
Chair

( categories: )

TWICE as much. Any theories

TWICE as much. Any theories as to why this could be? Cheap TVA juice, for example?

Ah!

It could use some more research to see where Jim Grimstead with DFA got his numbers and information.

I guess he would be easy enough to reach by email for more information.

John Edwards is the candidate of HOPE, I will vote for JRE 2008! Join me for real change, not money or media hype, but real change for America.

Alcoa?

How much of this happens in Blount County? Didn't Alcoa locate there for the cheap TVA electricity? (Is it still cheap?)

Liberty and justice for all.

My new home

R. Neal's picture
Cheap TVA power is your

Cheap TVA power is your answer. "Cheap" as in cents per KWH v. total costs to the environment that taxpayers and society subsidize. TVA has always promoted consumption, and pays only lip service to conservation.

Lovable, that's an interesting question. But, I believe that Alcoa actually owned the dams on the Little T at (besides Fontana and later Tellico) one point, and may still?

Russ's picture
The numbers

Although I would support every one of those initiatives listed under Bredesen's energy plan, the assertion that "Tennessee has the highest individual consumption of electricity in the country" is false. The sentence after it is also false ("Tennessee is also the greatest average monthly consumer of industrial electricity, using more than twice as much power as much larger states such as Texas and California.").

This table from the DOE shows that Tennessee's per capita consumption of electricity ranks us 13th in the nation, at roughly one third the per capita rate of California.

This table shows that we're 12th for industrial energy use, consuming only 12 percent of the amount Texas does.

~Russ

Anyone know where they got

Anyone know where they got these numbers?

I didn't see any numbers in the e-mail to verify.

Russ, that table doesn't appear to me to have the per capita figure for electricity. It gives the total electricity consumption by state, and the per capita number for total energy, but not per capita electricity.

At any rate, don't more people in this area use electric heating than other regions? That might explain part of the difference.

Brian A.

Russ's picture
Oops

Russ, that table doesn't appear to me to have the per capita figure for electricity.

Brian, you're right. This one places Tennessee 6th in the nation on per capita electricity use overall, which presumably includes industrial and commercial uses. This cached page from DOE says the following:

Tennessee electricity consumption is high and the State leads the United States in per capita residential electricity consumption. More than one-half of Tennessee households use electricity as their primary source of energy for home heating.

The second sentence of that quote might help explain the #1 rank; plus, it gets damn hot here in the summer, and we sure do love our A/C.

~Russ

An article in the Commercial Appeal

This article is an interesting look at concerns around the world with countries stepping up and some into the use of Nuclear power. An interesting read, and esp. for those who are pro nuclear energy and enlight of the post here today.

Nuclear power 'renaissance' poses problems
Can developing nations run plants safely?

By George Jahn
Associated Press
Sunday, January 13, 2008

VIENNA, Austria -- Global warming and rocketing oil prices are making nuclear power fashionable, drawing a once demonized industry out of the shadows of the Chernobyl disaster as a potential shining knight of clean energy.

Read the complete article click here.

John Edwards is the candidate of HOPE, I will vote for JRE 2008! Join me for real change, not money or media hype, but real change for America.

Makes sense to me

We have lived in California's central valley and New Mexico and now in East TN. Our daily electric usage is much higher here than either of those other two states and there is no real big difference to our life style between these states. So why do we use far more juice here? There is a difference to our types of cooling.

In NewMexico and California to cool the houses we used this thing called a swamp cooler which is very inexpensive to run but does require water to operate. Swamp coolers don't work at all when there is any humidity in the air so of course here in TN we are on a heat pump unit for chilled air.

The biggest difference in usage is simply the fact that we have to run our A/C at night here in TN while out west nightfall means it is time to find a jacket.

Well, yeah, but it's hotter

Well, yeah, but it's hotter in TX, and more humid in FL. And we're still using more than our share. It's a shame.

fair enough

However, the whole question as to why we use more electric is still unanswered.

Folks in TN don't use as many Christmas lights as folks UpNorth but are they less likely to replace that nine bulb bathroom vanity light from 1982 than folks in other states?

The answer must be in the amount of heating and cooling days and then add in the fact that TN uses more total electric systems than Ohio or NewMexico. I would rather see a Carbon Footprint type of comparison rather than a simple electric usage comparison.

I would rather see a Carbon

I would rather see a Carbon Footprint type of comparison rather than a simple electric usage comparison.

I think the BTU information in the table Russ linked to above is a better measurement of that than singling out electricity usage.

It's also worth pointing out that some of the electricity we use is hydro-generated (no greenhouse gases).

Brian A.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.