TN Dems Set to March Right Back into the "Constitutional Amendment" Trap

Submitted by Eleanor A on Mon, 01/14/2008 - 09:44.

Sorry for the double post this AM...lots happening this Monday...

(From later in the post, and the main point I'm trying to make: You'd think Dems would have learned from 2006, when many folks think the gay-marriage Constitutional amendment most likely cost Tennessee a Senate seat and the chance to elect the first Black Senator from the South since Reconstruction. It's disappointing to see Tennessee Democrats line up to support a lightning-rod social issue Constitutional amendment that will virtually guarantee a flood of right-wingers to the polls in 2010, the year Tennessee will elect its next Governor.)

This afternoon, SJ127, a measure designed to prevent the TN Constitution from protecting the right to abortion, will rear its ugly head on the floor of the Tennessee Senate once again. As is traditionally the case, it will be cosponsored by a passel of Republicans but also a couple of notable Tennessee Democrats, Sens. Tommy Kilby and Doug Henry. Again this year, it will be opposed by virtually all of the elected women Democratic Senators, including DavCo Sen. Thelma Harper, Memphis Sen. Beverly Marrero and Senate Speaker Pro Tem Rosalind Kurita, who gave a barnburner speech on her personal experiences as an OR nurse on the Senate floor last year. (Unfortunately Sen. Ford, who opposed SJ127 in 2007, is in the hospital and will be unable to cast her vote.)

Experience also indicates the bill will most likely pass the full Senate, as it's done each of the last four or so Senate sessions. Rumor on the street is that many in the TN Senate will support the TN Right to Life version of the bill with no exceptions for rape or incest (a strategem that may also be employed as a tactical measure by some woman Democrats, who want to see this thing hit the media in all its hateful glory.)

However, this year the political math is a bit different. In each of the last few years, the legislation has been stopped in the Public Health and Family Assistance Subcommittee of the House Health and Human Resources Committee, by five female Democratic Representatives (Jones, Sontany, Pruitt, Marrero, DeBerry). Rep. Marrero is now a Senator from Memphis, and new committee assignments determine that the measure may not be so easily defeated.

The GOP, of course, is out on the stump pretending the legislation will "only" weaken the TN Constitution, which was found in 2000 by the Supreme Court to be a stronger protector of the right to abortion than Roe v. Wade. Many groups, however, including TN Planned Parenthood, see it as a starting point for TN Right to Life to issue a full-scale assault on the right to choose in Tennessee.

This is certainly a depressing turn of events. Regardless of one's personal feelings on the subject, it's disappointing to see Tennessee Democrats line up to support a lightning-rod social issue Constitutional amendment that will virtually guarantee a flood of right-wingers to the polls in 2010, the year Tennessee will elect its next Governor. (More on how Constitutional amendments work: Link... )

You'd think they'd have learned from TN Democrats' experiences in 2006, when many folks think the gay-marriage Constitutional amendment most likely cost Tennessee a Senate seat and the chance to elect the first Black Senator from the South since Reconstruction. At one point R. Neal reported here that a group of TN Dems were considering an alternate amendment on stem cell research, but there hasn't been any public movement on that. I recall reading recently about a "hunter's rights" amendment threatened by the GOP, which may well still make an appearance this session.

So what can you do? Call your own Senator and urge him or her to oppose this fiasco. Contact your member in the House and do the same. Make a mental note to send a check to Reps. Jones, Sontany, Pruitt, or DeBerry, or state Sen. Marrero, after the session is over. Call Joanne Favors (615-741-2702), House member from Chattanooga who may be the swing vote on the House Public Health and Family Assistance subcommittee this year, and voice your support for her opposition to SJ127.

Those of you reading this from the 615 area code can also join your friends from NOW, Planned Parenthood, and a few other groups in bearing silent witness to this travesty at 5 PM this afternoon in the Senate chambers.

More info: PP of TN, 615-345-0952


R. Neal's picture
Great info and analysis, and

Great info and analysis, and thanks. Unfortunately, my senator is one of the mouth breathers who will be leading the way and helping light the torches and sharpen the pitchforks.

Those sharp pitchforks

... will come in handy should women in Tennessee lose our right to safe abortions entirely.

Sorry for the gallows humor, folks, but that's the way it is.

What you said

Elanor A.:

The real problem is not keeping the lime jello mold faithful AWAY from the polls. It's getting the dem/lib/progressive voters OUT TO VOTE. I know that's a hard job, but somebody's gonna have to do it. You can count on the Reptiliscum to always and forever have issues like this to throw in front of the snake handlers.

Democommie

Just a thought.

Great information for sure.

I think the lightning rod issues are important to what makes the difference between the two parties and makes it even more important to fight for the rights of all of us.

Even though to some certain issues seem to be for the few or few voices seem to speak up, there are many more for an issue that just may not be known.

I would rather continue to fight for what is right, not give up or consessions to serve being able to say the simple words "oh but, we got something done".

It is a shame that TN has such a division, but, I think no matter the issue, abortion or not, there is major fundamental differences in TN, and the republicans get out the vote will push through convincing again the fundamentalist on the right that there are no religious among the Democrats. Which they are sadly mistaken.

Another thought is they just seem in TN to be able to mobilize their voters better, get their message out better, use GOTV better.

Instead of running from an issue - I would like to see the blue storm through and build a true grassroots base, and a data base that is available across the state to get the vote out regardless of the issue that comes forward.

WE can feel bad about a controversial issue "raising it's ugly" head or we can learn how to inspire our voters to get to the polls more, and that their votes do make a difference.

Too many times, I hear "my vote doesn't matter". This is where our true fight is, with getting our voters to the polls and then together we can make TN Blue regardless of the issue. Banding the state together from East end to West end would also help, many times the information doesn't seem to get to all parts of the state. We need to build a far better network, north, east, south and west through TN, and the network needs to be available to all parts not just one section of TN. Raising funds for the state and county democratic parties is also something that would help. The republicans also seem to have this area down better also.

We fight on.

John Edwards is the candidate of HOPE, I will vote for JRE 2008! Join me for real change, not money or media hype, but real change for America.

R. Neal's picture
If I'm not mistaken,

Looks like Senate Republicans retreated. At least for now.

Sorry I'm so late with the

Sorry I'm so late with the update - was doing a little politicking over at the Capitol this evening.

The vote has been moved to Thursday at 9 AM...scuttlebutt is that leadership on the measure thought Monday "wasn't a good media day."

However, in more upbeat news, this bill may be dead in the water in the House subcommittee again this year. Sounds like we just may have the votes.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.