State GOP seeks to limit medical malpractice victim's rights
Submitted by R. Neal on Fri, 01/18/2008 - 07:23.
Sen. Paul Stanley (R-Memphis) has introduced "tort reform" bill SB2929, which limits medical malpractice awards to $250,000 for "noneconomic" damages, and reduces economic damages related to lost income by the amount of any unemployment, social security, or other benefits the victim might receive.
Victims would also have to specify the amount of damages they are seeking to recover. The amount is not disclosed to the jury, and if I read it correctly, the victim may not collect more than that amount even if the jury awards higher damages. It also allows payment of damages in installments.
The bill also limits the victim's contingent attorney fees, and allows a judge to set the fees. It places restrictions on expert testimony. It requires the victim to file an expert affidavit and medical records setting out the specifics of the claim. If the claim is dismissed because of a faulty or "bad faith" affidavit, the defendant is entitled to damages. The bill also requires the victim to file a HIPPA release that allows the defendant to access any of the victim's medical records, including mental health and drug/alcohol abuse treatment records, whether or not they are related to the claim.
The bill also eliminates the term "malpractice" and replaces it with "health care liability action" throughout Tennessee law.
The intent of this legislation is to make it harder to file a claim, harder to prove a claim, and harder to collect damages if they are awarded. It also increases the victim's financial risk in filing a claim, makes it harder for a victim of lesser means to get an attorney to represent them, and reduces a jury's power to award appropriate damages.
In short, it's a bad bill. It was a bad bill when it was introduced in the last session, and here's why.
Where's the bill to protect patients from incompetent doctors and negligent hospitals? Where are the bills to improve patient safety and outcomes? Where's the bill to make all malpractice and regulatory actions public and easily accessible so consumers can make informed choices about their health care and providers?
These steps would do more to reduce medical malpractice and the associated costs than trying to pretend it doesn't happen and make it disappear through hocus pocus "tort reform" legislation.
You should contact your state senator and representative and let them know this is a bad bill for health care consumers and ask what they are doing to promote patient safety.
Submitted by Anonymous on Fri, 01/18/2008 - 11:28.
Thanks for this info. This is beyond bad. Med mal cases are already extremely difficult, even where it is clear that the doc fouled up. The bottom line is that if docs cause death or injury to a patient, they, and especially their insurers, do not want to be responsible for their acts.
Most of the provisions in the bill mask it's true intent- to cap damages. Filing an expert's affidavit is a redundant requirement. As a practical matter, once you file a med mal lawsuit, the defense immediately files a motion for summary judgment with an affidavit from the offending doctor that says he/she did not deviate from the standard of care. The plaintiff then has only a few days to respond with a corresponding affidavit from a physician saying the opposite. The reality is that that affidavit cannot be obtained in that short a period of time, therefore the plaintiff has to have already lined up an expert who will do an affidavit at the time suit is filed.
The HIPPA release is granted automatically by the judge at the beginning of EVERY lawsuit involving personal injury. Also redundant.
Asking the plaintiff to declare damages up front is very dangerous- very often you don't know the full extent of damages until further treatment is obtained or further discovery occurs as part of the lawsuit. So what this requirement would do is limit the plaintiff to known damages at the time of filing, robbing the plaintiff of damages later determined, or later developing.
The docs and insurers want us to believe there is an epidemic of med mal causes causing premiums to escalate. Do the research on the internet as to how much is actually paid out on these claims. According to the state's statistics, 6 med mal cases went to trial in the entire state in 2004, and only 5 in 2005. Damages awarded in those cases were relatively minimal. Not quite an epidemic. And, if it's a "fivolous" case, the case is thrown out on motion for summary judgment- the remedy is already there.
The focus, by doctors and plaintiffs, should be on the insurers. Yes, in a lot of practice areas, premiums are ludicrous. A good cost:benefit analysis of the costs and payouts incurred by the insurers versus the income received from premiums is where the real inquiry should be. The info on this is out there- take a look at it. Heard of any med mal insurers going into receivership lately?
Docs have been duped into believing the simple proposition that frivolous claims have caused the high premiums, and docs believe this b/c the insurer, who is telling them this, is on their side.
Bottom line- if a doctor causes death or serious injury to a loved one of mine, and our legislators have limited damages for the physical and emotional pain, and financial hadship, caused by it, I am going to be furious. At this point, the advocacy/lobbying for PEOPLE does not match the lobbying of the Tenn. Medical Ass'n and insurers, so the legislature may do the wrong thing. But if this bill becomes law, the uproar and finger-pointing will be directed right back at the individual legislators and governor when the harsh consequences of this legislation are felt by real people.
I am a plaintiff's attorney, so some may say my view is skewed. But I can tell you as a practical matter our firm had more than 30 inquiries last year from potential med mal clients, and we have taken only 1 case. Why? Because even where it is clear that the doc fouled up, the law is already written in a way that makes it extremely difficult to succeed, due to several problem areas in the law. If this bill succeeds, count on the insurers being right back in front of the legislature for more tightening, year after year, until med mal is a thing of the past.
I called him before the minimum wage vote last time it was up, while he was still a Representative. He said that he had heard from a friend of his that had several Yogurt shops and he couldn't make it if minimum wage was rasied, he wouldn't be able to open any more locations that he was planning. And that all the minimum wage jobs were just held by High Schoolers, that they were meant as first time jobs.
And anyone who worked hard would get raises and move up rapidly, if they were willing to work hard.
The guy lives in a dream world!
Even when I worked at FedEx the pay raises were set at specific intervals, there were 2 different time periods, after getting to top out pay that I never got another raise for 5 years, no matter that the annual cost of living went up every year.
I can't even go into all the other parts of why we really need to find a replacement for Paul Stanley and get him voted out as soon as possible. He and Marsha Blackburn are must go's as far as I am concerned! The sooner the better.
John Edwards is the candidate of HOPE, I will vote for JRE 2008! Join me for real change, not money or media hype, but real change for America.
Submitted by Anonymous on Sat, 02/28/2009 - 15:27.
I have medical insurance and cannot see a doctor. I am permanently disabled by a doctor. I am alive and being murdered at the same time. The medical malpractice law is made to punish a patient again after he is injured.
Submitted by Anonymous on Tue, 03/03/2009 - 10:12.
It's not enough that in cases of malpractice the patient's health has suffered damages, they want to take the financial aid away as well? Covering the medical expenses doesn't cover the psychiatric ones.
___________ California Lemon Law Lawyers
Submitted by Anonymous on Wed, 06/10/2009 - 17:21.
This is not right. I will be contacting my state senator and representative. I will let them know that this is a bad bill for health care consumers. California Lemon Law
We've gotta get in the habit of relabelling Republican bullshit for what it is.
Liberty and justice for all.
My new home
Thanks for this info. This is beyond bad. Med mal cases are already extremely difficult, even where it is clear that the doc fouled up. The bottom line is that if docs cause death or injury to a patient, they, and especially their insurers, do not want to be responsible for their acts.
Most of the provisions in the bill mask it's true intent- to cap damages. Filing an expert's affidavit is a redundant requirement. As a practical matter, once you file a med mal lawsuit, the defense immediately files a motion for summary judgment with an affidavit from the offending doctor that says he/she did not deviate from the standard of care. The plaintiff then has only a few days to respond with a corresponding affidavit from a physician saying the opposite. The reality is that that affidavit cannot be obtained in that short a period of time, therefore the plaintiff has to have already lined up an expert who will do an affidavit at the time suit is filed.
The HIPPA release is granted automatically by the judge at the beginning of EVERY lawsuit involving personal injury. Also redundant.
Asking the plaintiff to declare damages up front is very dangerous- very often you don't know the full extent of damages until further treatment is obtained or further discovery occurs as part of the lawsuit. So what this requirement would do is limit the plaintiff to known damages at the time of filing, robbing the plaintiff of damages later determined, or later developing.
The docs and insurers want us to believe there is an epidemic of med mal causes causing premiums to escalate. Do the research on the internet as to how much is actually paid out on these claims. According to the state's statistics, 6 med mal cases went to trial in the entire state in 2004, and only 5 in 2005. Damages awarded in those cases were relatively minimal. Not quite an epidemic. And, if it's a "fivolous" case, the case is thrown out on motion for summary judgment- the remedy is already there.
The focus, by doctors and plaintiffs, should be on the insurers. Yes, in a lot of practice areas, premiums are ludicrous. A good cost:benefit analysis of the costs and payouts incurred by the insurers versus the income received from premiums is where the real inquiry should be. The info on this is out there- take a look at it. Heard of any med mal insurers going into receivership lately?
Docs have been duped into believing the simple proposition that frivolous claims have caused the high premiums, and docs believe this b/c the insurer, who is telling them this, is on their side.
Bottom line- if a doctor causes death or serious injury to a loved one of mine, and our legislators have limited damages for the physical and emotional pain, and financial hadship, caused by it, I am going to be furious. At this point, the advocacy/lobbying for PEOPLE does not match the lobbying of the Tenn. Medical Ass'n and insurers, so the legislature may do the wrong thing. But if this bill becomes law, the uproar and finger-pointing will be directed right back at the individual legislators and governor when the harsh consequences of this legislation are felt by real people.
I am a plaintiff's attorney, so some may say my view is skewed. But I can tell you as a practical matter our firm had more than 30 inquiries last year from potential med mal clients, and we have taken only 1 case. Why? Because even where it is clear that the doc fouled up, the law is already written in a way that makes it extremely difficult to succeed, due to several problem areas in the law. If this bill succeeds, count on the insurers being right back in front of the legislature for more tightening, year after year, until med mal is a thing of the past.
They love that phrase "tort reform".
John Edwards is the candidate of HOPE, I will vote for JRE 2008! Join me for real change, not money or media hype, but real change for America.
my email to Paul Stanley, sadly he is my Senator.
I called him before the minimum wage vote last time it was up, while he was still a Representative. He said that he had heard from a friend of his that had several Yogurt shops and he couldn't make it if minimum wage was rasied, he wouldn't be able to open any more locations that he was planning. And that all the minimum wage jobs were just held by High Schoolers, that they were meant as first time jobs.
And anyone who worked hard would get raises and move up rapidly, if they were willing to work hard.
The guy lives in a dream world!
Even when I worked at FedEx the pay raises were set at specific intervals, there were 2 different time periods, after getting to top out pay that I never got another raise for 5 years, no matter that the annual cost of living went up every year.
I can't even go into all the other parts of why we really need to find a replacement for Paul Stanley and get him voted out as soon as possible. He and Marsha Blackburn are must go's as far as I am concerned! The sooner the better.
John Edwards is the candidate of HOPE, I will vote for JRE 2008! Join me for real change, not money or media hype, but real change for America.
I have medical insurance and cannot see a doctor. I am permanently disabled by a doctor. I am alive and being murdered at the same time. The medical malpractice law is made to punish a patient again after he is injured.
It's not enough that in cases of malpractice the patient's health has suffered damages, they want to take the financial aid away as well? Covering the medical expenses doesn't cover the psychiatric ones.
___________
California Lemon Law Lawyers
منتديات كويتيات منتديات كويتيات | منتدى كويتيات التجاري منتدى كويتيات التجاري | سوق كويتيات سوق كويتيات | منتدى كويتيات منتدى كويتيات | كويتيات كويتيات | سوالف كويتيات سوالف كويتيات | سيدات اعمال الكويت منتدى سيدات اعمال الكويت | موقع كويتيات موقع كويتيات | حواء الكويت حواء الكويت | ;,djdhj ;,djdhj | منتديات منتديات | منتدى منتدى | دردشة كويتيات دردشة كويتيات | شات كويتيات شات كويتيات | كويتيات كويتيات | كويتيات نت كويتيات نت | دليل كويتيات دليل كويتيات
شات سعودي شات سعودي | دردشة سعودية دردشة سعودية | شات كويتي شات كويتي | دردشة كويتية دردشة كويتية | شات الحب شات الحب | شات دلع شات دلع | شات الرياض شات الرياض
سعودي سعودي | سعودية سعودية | كويتي كويتي | كويتية كويتية | الحب الحب | دلع دلع | الرياض الرياض
الخليج الخليج | دردشة الخليج دردشة الخليج | شات الخليج شات الخليج
موقع الخليج موقع الخليج | دردشة دردشة | شات شات
دردشة
دردشة كتابية
شات
رجيم
الشهد
منتدى الشهد
منتدى الشهد
دليل
غاليتي
منتدى غاليتي
منتتديات غاليتي
دليل مواقع
بنات دلع
منتدى بنات دلع
منتدى بنات دلع
دليل المواقع
دردشه صوتيه
شات صوتي
منتديات
برامج
دليل دردشات
صور
شات صوتي
دردشة صوتية
عسل
شات صوتي
دردشه صوتيه
منتدى
منابع الابداع
منتدى منابع الابداع
توبيكات
شات الخليج
شات الحب
شات السعودية
شات
دردشه
دردشة
دردشة بنات
دردشة السعودية
دردشة عربية
شات صوتي
مكياج 2009
أزياء سهرة 2009
شات جده
شات الاحساء
شات الدمام
شات الرياض
دردشة صوتية
دردشة الكويت
دردشة الامارات
دردشة عمان
دردشة قطر
دردشة البحرين
دردشة العراق
دردشة اليمن
دردشة سعودية
دردشة كتابية
شات كتابي
عروس 2009
بنات
ترافيان
الرياض
فيديو
حواء
الخليج
افلام
وزارة التربية والتعليم
ماسنجر
قصص
ترجمة
الود
الشله
video
اليوتيوب
راشد الماجد
عكاظ
بلياردو
العربية
توبيكات ملونه
توبيكات 2009
توبكات
توبيكات 2009
توبيكات للبنات
توبيكات بنات
توبيكات رمضان
كورة
الوطن
قوقل
جريدة الرياض
اليوم
اغاني
سعودي
شات سعودي
سعودي
خليجي
عربي
منتديات السعودية
منتديات الكويت
منتديات الامارات
منتديات عمان
منتديات قطر
منتديات البحرين
منتديات العراق
منتديات اليمن
منتدى بنات
خدمات
مسجات
منتديات
منتدى
عالم حواء
العاب بنات
العاب فلاش
العاب
دليل
موقع
يوتيوب
جوال
الجامعات
YouTube
Business
online
Roro 44
برامج
حب
قصات شعر 2009
الحياة الزوجية
ياسر القحطاني
Mobile
university
Tourism
Travel
صور
ستار اكاديمي 6
online games
Internet
Directory
Free Download
Games
This is not right. I will be contacting my state senator and representative. I will let them know that this is a bad bill for health care consumers.
California Lemon Law
العاب
العاب
نتائج الثانويه العامه
تحميل صور
ثيمات
طبخ
الرشاقة
طفلك
ازياء 2009
العاب بنات
ازياء
صور
العاب بنات
ماسنجر
منتدى
الجوال
توبيكات
ثيمات
يوتيوب
العاب
عالم حواء
تسريحات "مكياج رقيق وناعم
تسريحات 2009 "اكسسوارات
العاب اطفال "العاب اجهزه
العاب فضائيه "العاب ديكور
العاب بنات
االعاب سيارات
منال العالم
مطبخ منال العالم
طبخات منال العالم
توبيكات
توبيكات
العاب بنات
BlackBerry برنامج برنامج الماسنجر Windows Live Messenger
ماسنجر البلاك بيري
بلاك بيري
العاب
شات طرب
طلال
دليل قلوب
دليل حنون
دليل طيف
دليل حلوه
الهنوف
المحاربه
دليل المهاجر
دليل المسافر
دليل مسافر
دليل النور
دليل سافر
دليل الرمال
دليل وناسه
دليل حبايبنا
دليل حلوين
كويت 25
كويت كام
دردشة فله
دليل ون
دليل ثري
دليل قسوة
دليل الرحيل
دليل رحيل
دليل انهاز
دليل اشواق
حب كام
دليل حبتين
دليل
السعوديه
دليل المهاجر
دليل النمور
دليل نمور
دليل هلا
دليل حلوين
دليل الحان
دليل شمس
دليل
الدنيا
دليل قطر
دليل
رايقين
دليل رايق
دليل روائع
دردشة رجه
دليل سحايب
دليل ليالي
شبكة مون لايت
دليل
زكرتيه
دليل الكون
دليل اشواق
دليل سعودي
دليل سنتوب
دليل توب
دليل
الامارات
دليل زقرتيه
دليل زقرتي
دليل سحالي
دليل رائع
قطر كام
دليل الحره
دليل هنوفه
دليل الكلام
دليل سحابه
دليل تو
دليل فور
دليل فايف
دليل سكس
دليل نواعم
دليل نواعم
دليل حب
شات حورية
فلها وربك
يحلها
ريم كام
دليل روح الغلا
دليل سوريا
دليل همسات
دليل قلبي
قلوب
طرب
دردشة , منتديات
,
دليل مواقع ,
مون لايت ,
شات صوتي
,
دردشه
صوتيه,
شات كتابي ,
دردشه كتابية
,
بلوتوث
دردشه صوتيه ,
دردشه
, برامج
,
افلام
,
صور
,
يوتيوب
,
ازياء
,
الارشيف
,
منتدى
,
توبيكات
,
صور سيارات
ديكور
,
حواء
,
خواطر
,
اخبار الفن
,
نكت ,
قصص ,
العاب ,
شات
,
كويتي كام ,
كويت كام ,
دردشة صوتية ,
دردشة كتابية
,
شات كتابي
,
دردشه
كتابيه ,
ثقافه جنسيه
,
الثقافه الجنسيه ,
ثقافة الجنس
,
شعراء
دليل مواقع ,
قصائد ,
منتديات ,
توبيكات
,
دليل مواقع
,
شات كتابي -
يوتيوب
-
مقاطع
يوتيوب ,
شات صوتي كويتي ,
شات كويتي
,
دردشة
صوتية كويتية ,
دردشه صوتيه كويتيه ,
شات كتابي
كويتي ,
دردشة
كتابية كويتية
,
دردشه
كتابيه كويتيه ,
شات صوتي
,
مسجات
الجوال
يوتيوب اسلامي -
يوتيوب مقاطع حيوانات
-
يوتيوب مسلسلات -
يوتيوب افلام - سينما
يوتيوب تفحيط سيارات -
يوتيوب الكاميرا الخفيه
-
يوتيوب مقاطع مضحكه
sitemap
بروكسيات
-
بروكسي -
برنامج يفتح المواقع المحجوبه -
ترافيان