Democratic Presidential Candidates - Senate Voting Record Comparison

Submitted by bizgrrl on Sun, 02/03/2008 - 08:49.

Here is a summary of the Senate voting records for the Senator from Illinois, Barack Obama, and the Senator from New York, Hillary Clinton, for the years 2005 through 2007.

The summary is based on the Project Vote Smart selection of Key Votes. The comparison includes years 2005 through 2007 because that is the length of Senate terms the two Senators have served together and had the opportunity to vote on the same bills.

2007
----
77 Total Senate Key Votes for 2007
64 Times both voted the same or both did not vote.
13 Times voted differently

2006
----
58 Total Senate Key Votes for 2006
53 Times both voted the same or both did not vote.
5 Times voted differently

2005
----
109 Total Senate Key Votes for 2005
103 Times both voted the same or both did not vote.
6 Times voted differently

Voting difference details after the jump...



2007
----
77 Total Senate Key Votes for 2007 per Project Vote Smart
64 Times both voted the same or both did not vote.
13 Times voted differently


Date Description Bill Number IL-Obama NY-Clinton
10/3/2007  Border Fence and Customs Appropriations S Amdt 3117  Obama NV  Clinton Y
9/27/2007  SCHIP Reauthorization HR 976  Obama NV  Clinton Y
9/26/2007  Regarding Iran and the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps S Amdt 3017  Obama NV  Clinton Y
9/26/2007  Regarding Federalism in Iraq S Amdt 2997  Obama NV  Clinton Y
9/20/2007 Support for General Petraeus and Armed Forces  S Amdt 2934  Obama NV  Clinton N
7/26/2007  REAL ID Funding S Amdt 2405  Obama NV  Clinton Y
7/26/2007  Border Fence and Customs Appropriations S Amdt 2480  Obama NV  Clinton Y
7/26/2007  Implementing the 9/11 Commission Recommendations Act HR 1  Obama NV  Clinton Y
7/26/2007  Department of Homeland Security Appropriations HR 2638  Obama NV  Clinton Y
7/20/2007  Student Loan Lender Subsidy Cuts and Student Grants HR 2669  Obama NV  Clinton Y
7/19/2007  Sense of the Senate on Guantanamo Bay Detainees S Amdt 2351  Obama NV  Clinton Y
6/11/2007  Attorney General No Confidence Vote S J Res 14  Obama NV  Clinton Y
5/7/2007  FDA Drug Import Certification Amendment S Amdt 1010  Obama NV  Clinton N



2006
----
58 Total Senate Key Votes for 2006 per Project Vote Smart
53 Times both voted the same or both did not vote.
5 Times voted differently


Date Description Bill Number IL-Obama NY-Clinton
9/6/2006  Cluster Munitions Amendment HR 5631  Obama Y  Clinton N
8/1/2006  Gulf of Mexico Energy Security Act of 2006 S 3711  Obama N  Clinton Y
7/13/2006  Firearm Confiscation Prohibition Amendment HR 5441  Obama Y  Clinton N
7/11/2006  USEMA Amendment HR 5441  Obama Y  Clinton N
2/2/2006  Tax Reconciliation bill HR 4297  Obama N  Clinton Y



2005
----
109 Total Senate Key Votes for 2005 per Project Vote Smart
103 Times both voted the same or both did not vote.
6 Times voted differently


Date Description Bill Number IL-Obama NY-Clinton
11/18/2005  Tax Reconciliation Bill S 2020  Obama N  Clinton Y
7/29/2005  Energy Policy Act of 2005 HR 6  Obama Y  Clinton N
6/14/2005  Thomas B. Griffith - US Circuit Judge PN 202  Obama Y  Clinton N
6/9/2005  Richard A Griffin - US Circuit Judge PN 195  Obama NV  Clinton Y
4/18/2005  Future Military Funding for Iraq Amendment HR 1268  Obama NV  Clinton Y
3/10/2005  Bankruptcy Reform Bill S 256  Obama N  Clinton NV

Interesting comment at

Interesting comment at WhitesCreek:

I find it interesting that while Clinton stood up and voted against the measure to condemn MoveOn (for that Petraeus ad), Obama ... failed to vote on it at all, yet the members "endorsed" him.

This point did not come to mind when I was reviewing the Senate votes.

However, I did notice Obama did vote on something else that day, Expressing Support for All Men and Women in the U.S. Armed Forces.

For some reason, Obama elected to not vote on the other bill presented that day.

Vote to pass an amendment to reaffirm support for all men and women of the United States Armed Forces, to strongly condemn any attacks on General David Petraeus and all members of the US Armed Forces and to specifically condemn Moveon.org’s advertisement about General David Petraeus.

Thus, distancing himself from any controversy. Obama is allowing condemnation of Moveon.org and anyone that might attack Petraeus verbally or in written form.

So, he drew a fine line,

So, he drew a fine line, that was very telling, I believe. I think I like it. Somehow at the time, I didn't realize that the resolution had so many different amendments. pgs

Pam Strickland

OK

Do you have a link for this work at Project Vote Smart.

It is interesting to note that some votes on some issues are not as important to one as they may be to another. Isn't the work at Project Vote done by volunteers? If it is the work is somewhat suspect.

2005 In the 109th First session there were 366 votes
2006 In the 109th Second session there were 279 votes
2007 In the 110th First session there were 442 votes

A total of 1087 and they selected 244 votes,

109 of those 244 they used Obama very first year in, while most follow suit with their party in votes and don't necessarily reflect their true voting pattern as they are new and learning.

I have said along with Jonathan Alter (Newsweek) that there is little difference in Obama and Clinton, it was Edwards that was the progressive.

Just some points.

The best has suspended his campaign and can still receive delegates, supporters are still voting for Edwards, who knows now where we go.

Terry Troll's picture
Whoops.

follow suit with their party in votes and don't necessarily reflect their true voting pattern as they are new and learning...
I thought he would be ready day one?

Number of No votes by Obama

Now I understand why Obama claims himself as the Washington outsider... He either choose to avoid controversial votes OR he was absent for them more times than Hillary or Edwards. I am really nervous that Republican political machine has a calculated plan to boast him into Democratic ticket and kill Democrats in Nov by having a middle-line candidate of their own... Same as the same-sex marriage proposition which killed J.Kerry in 2004. Let's get smart and look beyond the rhetoric... I wish we had a clear candidate with less controversy and clear direction. Obama scares me as the empty vessel. While Hillary has her own shade of issues, she may be realistically the more electable one in Nov.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Captcha
This question is used to make sure you are a human visitor and to prevent spam submissions.
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.